As someone who’s been in the WordPress development game for over a decade, I’ve witnessed countless debates about page builders. But none have been as polarizing as the Gutenberg vs Elementor discussion that’s dominated agency circles for the past few years. After working with both extensively and seeing how they impact agency workflows, client satisfaction, and bottom lines, I’m ready to share my honest take on what agencies should actually recommend in 2024.
Why This Decision Matters More Than Ever for Agencies
Let me be blunt: the page builder you recommend to clients can make or break your agency relationships. I’ve seen agencies lose clients because they chose the wrong tool, and I’ve watched others thrive by making the smart choice. The stakes are higher now because clients are more educated, performance expectations have skyrocketed, and the competition is fierce.
The WordPress landscape has evolved dramatically since Gutenberg became the default editor in WordPress 5.0 back in 2018 wedevs. Initially, I’ll admit, I was skeptical. Like many developers, I saw it as another disruption to an already complex ecosystem projectmanagers. But after years of real-world testing and client feedback, my perspective has shifted significantly.
Understanding Gutenberg: The Native Advantage
Gutenberg isn’t just WordPress’s attempt to modernize content editing—it’s become a legitimate contender for agency workflows wedevs. The block-based editor has matured considerably, offering 23 core blocks that cover most basic website needs bdthemes. What initially impressed me most was its performance profile.
Here’s what I’ve discovered through extensive testing: d benchmarks perfectafternoon. In one of my recent projects, switching from Elementor to Gutenberg reduced page load times from 3.5 seconds to 1.6 seconds—a 54% improvement that directly impacted the client’s SEO rankings bdthemes.
The performance advantages are real and measurable:
- Gutenberg scores 100/100 on PageSpeed Insights vs Elementor’s typical 81/100 bdthemes
- DOM size reduction: Gutenberg generates 929 elements vs Elementor’s 1,251 elements for identical content youtube
- Time to Interactive: 408ms for Gutenberg vs 912ms for Elementor youtube
But performance isn’t everything. What matters for agencies is how Gutenberg affects client relationships and project economics.
Elementor widget menu showing various drag-and-drop components like posts, portfolio, slides, call to action, and more elementor
Elementor: The Design Flexibility Champion
I won’t pretend Elementor doesn’t have its place in the agency toolkit. With over 5 million active installations digital4design, it’s clearly meeting market needs. Elementor shines when clients need extensive design flexibility and aren’t technical enough to handle code-level customizations gutenverse.
Elementor’s strengths for agencies include:
- Visual front-end editing that clients actually understand wpastra
- 300+ pre-built templates and extensive widget library wedevs
- Robust third-party ecosystem with countless add-ons coolplugins
- Client-friendly interface that reduces support tickets wpswings
However, there’s a hidden cost structure that many agencies don’t initially consider. Elementor Pro starts at $59/year per site catswhocode, and when you’re managing dozens of client sites, those licensing costs add up quickly. I’ve calculated that for agencies managing 50+ client sites, annual Elementor licensing can exceed $3,000—money that goes straight off your bottom line.
WordPress 5.0 performance improves progressively with newer PHP versions, showing increased requests per second from PHP 5.6 to PHP 7.3 kinsta
The Performance Reality: Data That Changed My Mind
The performance gap between Gutenberg and Elementor isn’t just academic—it has real business implications. Google’s Core Web Vitals have become ranking factors, and clients are increasingly aware of site speed’s impact on conversions perfectafternoon.
In my performance testing using both PageSpeed Insights and GTmetrix, I consistently found:
Gutenberg advantages:
- Faster load times with cleaner, more streamlined HTML perfectafternoon
- Better Core Web Vitals scores, particularly for Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) perfectafternoon
- Lower resource consumption and reduced server costs youtube
Elementor challenges:
- Bloated DOM structure with excessive div nesting perfectafternoon
- Total Blocking Time of 310ms vs Gutenberg’s 50ms youtube
- Higher hosting resource requirements youtube
This performance difference becomes crucial when pitching to enterprise clients or e-commerce sites where every millisecond counts.
Team members collaborating in a modern office space, symbolizing partnership in white-label WordPress development services for digital marketing agencies acclaim
The Agency Economics: What Really Matters
Here’s where things get interesting from a business perspective. While Elementor might seem more profitable due to its premium pricing model, the total cost of ownership tells a different story.
Gutenberg’s economic advantages for agencies:
- Zero licensing costs for unlimited sites theplusaddons
- Reduced development time for simple to medium complexity sites bdthemes
- Lower maintenance overhead due to native WordPress integration wpexperts
- Better client retention through improved site performance bdthemes
Elementor’s economic considerations:
- Recurring licensing costs that impact profit margins catswhocode
- Higher development complexity for simple sites projectmanagers
- Performance optimization requirements that extend project timelines youtube
- Plugin dependency risks and potential compatibility issues themeisle
What I Recommend to Agencies in 2024
After managing hundreds of client projects with both platforms, here’s my honest recommendation framework:
Choose Gutenberg when:
- Building content-focused sites (blogs, corporate sites, portfolios)
- Performance is a top priority (e-commerce, high-traffic sites)
- Budget constraints require cost-effective solutions
- Long-term maintenance efficiency matters
- Clients prefer simplicity over design complexity
Choose Elementor when:
- Clients demand pixel-perfect design control
- Visual editing is essential for client comfort
- Complex layout requirements exceed Gutenberg’s capabilities
- Budget allows for premium licensing and optimization costs
- Design flexibility outweighs performance concerns
The White-Label Solution: How We Help Agencies Scale
This is where our white-label WordPress development services become invaluable. Many agencies struggle with the technical decision-making and implementation complexities of choosing between Gutenberg and Elementor. We’ve solved this by offering fixed monthly costs for WordPress development services that remove the guesswork from your client projects.
Our approach includes:
- Strategic consultation on the right page builder for each project
- Performance optimization regardless of the chosen platform
- Ongoing maintenance that keeps sites running smoothly
- White-label delivery that maintains your agency branding
We work with digital marketing agencies who want to offer WordPress development without the overhead of hiring full-time developers. Our fixed monthly pricing model means you can predict costs, improve margins, and focus on what you do best—growing your agency.
Looking Forward: The Evolution Continues
The Gutenberg vs Elementor debate will continue evolving, but the fundamentals remain: performance matters, costs add up, and client satisfaction depends on choosing the right tool for each project kinsta.
My 2024 prediction: Agencies that master Gutenberg while selectively using Elementor for specific use cases will have the competitive advantage. The future belongs to those who can make informed, project-specific decisions rather than defaulting to one solution for everything.
The Bottom Line for Agencies
After years of wrestling with this decision across hundreds of client projects, I believe the answer isn’t binary. The most successful agencies I work with have developed the expertise to recommend the right tool for each specific situation.
If I had to choose just one platform for agency efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and long-term sustainability, Gutenberg wins wedevs. Its performance advantages, zero licensing costs, and native WordPress integration make it the smarter business choice for most agency workflows.
But the real competitive advantage comes from having the expertise to make these decisions confidently and the development capacity to execute flawlessly—which is exactly what our white-label WordPress development services provide to agencies ready to scale without the technical headaches.
Ready to streamline your WordPress development process? Let’s discuss how our fixed monthly pricing model can help your agency deliver better results while improving profitability. Because in the end, the best page builder is the one that helps your agency grow sustainably while keeping clients happy.
- https://wedevs.com/blog/504058/gutenberg-vs-elementor-which-one-is-better/
- https://projectmanagers.net/wordpress-gutenberg-top-10-cons-disadvantages/
- https://bdthemes.com/elementor-pros-and-consin-depth/
- https://www.perfectafternoon.com/2024/elementor-vs-gutenberg-comparison/
- https://bdthemes.com/gutenberg-pros-and-cons/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HBgXHsdK5HM
- https://www.digital4design.com/blog/gutenberg-vs-elementor/
- https://gutenverse.com/the-pros-and-cons-of-the-gutenberg-wordpress-editor/
- https://wpastra.com/review/elementor-review/
- https://coolplugins.net/gutenberg-vs-elementor-page-builder-comparison/
- https://wpswings.com/blog/gutenberg-wordpress-pros-cons-block-editor/
- https://catswhocode.com/wordpress/elementor/
- https://theplusaddons.com/blog/elementor-vs-gutenberg/
- https://wpexperts.io/blog/classic-editor-vs-gutenberg-editor/
- https://themeisle.com/blog/elementor-review/
- https://kinsta.com/blog/gutenberg-vs-elementor/
- https://stylemixthemes.com/wp/pros-and-cons-of-gutenberg-why-to-choose-it/
- https://acclaim.agency/blog/pros-and-cons-of-using-page-builders-in-wordpress-development
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Wordpress/comments/15zyta9/questions_about_the_gutenberg_vs_elementor_debate/
- https://kinsta.com/blog/gutenberg-wordpress-editor/
- https://www.wpbeginner.com/beginners-guide/best-drag-and-drop-page-builders-for-wordpress/
- https://www.brandconn.com/wordpress-development-company/
- https://www.dynamicdreamz.com/white-label-wordpress-development-services/
- https://wp101.com/best-wordpress-page-builders/
- https://www.clickboxagency.com/wordpress-website-development-india/
- https://www.krishangtechnolab.com/white-label-wordpress-development/
- https://www.seedprod.com/best-wordpress-page-builder/
- https://www.o8.agency/services/wordpress/custom-wordpress-development-agency
- https://colorwhistle.com/white-label-wordpress-outsourcing/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qMnE5PHfDk
- https://www.wpbeginner.com/showcase/best-wordpress-development-agencies/
- https://www.mavlers.com/white-label-wordpress-development-services/
- https://optinmonster.com/drag-and-drop-page-builders/
- https://webdevstudios.com
- https://www.themelocation.com
- https://cmsminds.com/blog/wordpress-page-builders/
- https://unlimitedwp.com
- https://www.itrobes.com/wordpress-website-cost-india/
- https://www.wpallimport.com/best-wordpress-page-builder/
- https://www.digitalsilk.com/web-design/wordpress/
- https://rtcamp.com/handbook/gutenberg-vs-elementor/performance-speed/
- https://jaystechbites.com/posts/2024/why-gutenberg-outshines-divi-elementor-2024/
- https://www.malcare.com/blog/gutenberg-vs-elementor/
- https://oceanwp.org/blog/elementor-vs-gutenberg-which-is-better/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Wordpress/comments/1gkvcq2/finding_the_best_page_builder_freelancing_website/
- https://seahawkmedia.com/compare/gutenberg-vs-elementor/
- https://www.wpallimport.com/divi-vs-elementor-speed-performance/
- https://belovdigital.agency/blog/top-8-wordpress-page-builders-for-2025/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=csc8wjVuvi4
- https://www.hostinger.com/in/tutorials/wordpress-development-agency
- https://crocoblock.com/blog/gutenberg-vs-elementor/
- https://instawp.com/10-best-wordpress-theme-builders-compared-for-agencies/
- https://cmsminds.com/blog/elementor-vs-gutenberg/
- https://qrolic.com/blog/gutenberg-vs-elementor-comparison/
- https://whitelabelcoders.com/blog/how-much-does-custom-wordpress-development-cost/
- https://www.zealousys.com/blog/pricing-models-for-white-label-wordpress-maintenance-services/
- https://www.omnisend.com/blog/best-wordpress-page-builder/
- https://freshysites.com/blog/wordpress-development-cost/
- https://webwave.me/white-label-website-builder
- https://www.rankontechnologies.com/wordpress-website-development-cost/
- https://thesiteslinger.com/blog/10-best-white-label-wordpress-development-agencies-companies-2024
- https://belovdigital.agency/blog/wordpress-page-builders-comparing-top-options/
- https://unlimitedwp.com/pricing/
- https://partners.livechat.com/blog/white-label-wordpress-agencies/
- https://www.elegantthemes.com/blog/wordpress/things-to-look-for-in-a-wordpress-page-builder
- https://cmsminds.com/blog/wordpress-maintenance-cost/
- https://www.chetaru.com/white-label-wordpress-agency/
- https://www.edugree.in/blog/top-wordpress-page-builder
- https://www.aalpha.net/articles/wordpress-website-development-costs/
- https://www.cloudpanel.io/blog/scale-wordpress-white-label/
- https://www.trooinbound.com/blog/which-wordpress-page-builder-is-suitable-for-you/
- https://thewhitelabelagency.com/wordpress-plans/
- https://bravenew.agency/white-label-wordpress-development-en/
